Selling a House in Long Island Without a Realtor (FSBO vs. a Cash Offer)

Selling a home is arguably the largest financial transaction you will ever make. The incentive to cut out the middleman is massive. In an expensive state like New York, where the median home sale price is often more than half a million dollars according to June Redfin data, saving that average 6% agent commission represents tens of thousands of dollars in your pocket.

To avoid the commission, you generally have two main options For Sale By Owner (FSBO) or selling directly to a professional cash buyer: A company like WeBuyPropertyNY that uses cash to close fast. Many homeowners find themselves asking: how can I sell my house fast without a realtor and still come out ahead? The answer depends entirely on how much risk, time, and emotional labor you are willing to invest.

The FSBO Problem

When you choose the FSBO route on Long Island, you are essentially taking on a taxing second job with no guaranteed paycheck. You save the 6% commission, but you assume all the risk, liability, and work that an experienced agent and their brokerage typically handle. This workload is particularly heavy in New York, a state with rigid closing procedures.

The Heavy Lifting of Marketing and Management

Acting as your own agent requires you to become a marketing and sales expert overnight.

• Professional Listings: Buyers in competitive markets like Long Island are highly sophisticated. They are often comparing your property against listings handled by top agents. You cannot simply snap a few photos with your phone and expect offers to pour in. You need high-definition images, a compelling written description that captures the property’s value, and the time to upload and manage listings across various platforms. If your listing looks amateur, sophisticated buyers will assume the house is poorly maintained or that the owner is inexperienced.
• Constant Availability: How can I sell my house fast without a realtor if I am stuck answering phone calls and emails all day? You become the point of contact for every query, every showing, and every negotiation. Your phone will ring at all hours—from qualified buyers, unqualified “lookers,” and persistent agents hoping you will eventually list with them. The administrative and screening burden is constant and requires immense effort.

The Financial Burden of Repairs and Legal Risk

One of the biggest hurdles FSBO sellers face is the physical condition of the property and the legal disclosures required in New York.

Mandatory Disclosure Laws

Even if you save the commission, you still face mandatory legal obligations:

Attorney Closing State: New York is an Attorney Closing State. This is a critical piece of local expertise. You are legally required to retain a Real Estate Attorney to draft the contract, hold escrow, manage the closing, and ensure the transfer of the Property Deed. Even when you sell FSBO, you cannot bypass this significant professional fee.

The Inspection and Repair Trap

Traditional buyers, backed by mortgages, are looking for a move-in ready home. Their offer will be contingent on a home inspection.

The inspector, hired by the buyer, will go through your property with a fine-tooth comb, looking for anything from a cracked foundation to old HVAC system components or potential Zoning Violations from past home additions. Once the report comes back, the buyer will almost certainly:

• Demand Repairs: Require you to spend thousands of dollars out of pocket to fix issues before closing.
• Negotiate a Lower Price: Demand a massive price reduction to cover the cost of the repairs they will undertake.

If you cannot afford the cash for major repairs, the buyer will walk away. You will have wasted months and still be stuck with a house that needs work and now has a failed contract history.

The Uncertainty of the Traditional Closing Timeline

Even if you successfully navigate the marketing, legal paperwork, and repair negotiations, the traditional closing timeline creates immense stress.

Waiting for the Bank: Most traditional Long Island buyers need a mortgage. You are at the mercy of the banking system and must wait 45 to 60 days for the buyer’s bank to process the loan and complete the underwriting.

Appraisal Risk: During the waiting period, the bank will order an Appraisal. If the bank appraiser determines the house is worth less than the agreed-upon price (a low appraisal), the bank will not lend the full amount. This almost always forces the buyer to walk away, or it requires you, the seller, to dramatically lower the price at the last minute.

The Cash Offer Solution

There is a second option that solves the problems associated with FSBO while still achieving your primary goal of keeping the agent commission. This involves selling directly to a professional, high-volume cash home buyer like WeBuyPropertyNY. This method is designed for unparalleled speed, convenience, and financial certainty.

Zero Commissions, Clear Costs, and Local Expertise

WeBuyPropertyNY is a locally focused company that has completed hundreds of cash transactions across Long Island, specializing in fast, certain, cash closings. Our process is designed for transparency:

• 0% Commission: We honor your goal of saving the commission. We charge zero agent fees.
• Transparent Seller Costs: We are upfront that New York sellers must still cover two mandatory financial obligations: The NY State Transfer Tax and your Attorney Fees.
• We Cover the Rest: WeBuyPropertyNY covers all other standard closing costs typically borne by the seller, including Title Insurance fees and most prorations.

Eliminating the Work and Stress

The biggest advantage is the total removal of effort. When you sell to WeBuyPropertyNY, you do zero work.

No Repairs, No Cleaning: We buy the house exactly “as is,” regardless of the condition. You do not need to fix the roof, replace the old furnace, or even clean before you leave.

No Showings, No Negotiations: You bypass the entire marketing circus. There are no showings, no open houses, no screening of unqualified buyers, and no lengthy negotiations over inspection reports.

Speed and Certainty

The most significant advantage of a cash sale is the timeline and guaranteed outcome.

Guaranteed Closing in 14 Days: You eliminate the bank bottleneck. Because WeBuyPropertyNY uses cash, there are no mortgage applications, no underwriters, and zero risk of the sale collapsing due to a low bank appraisal. We can close in as little as 14 days, or on a date of your choosing.

Guaranteed Exit Strategy: This certainty is priceless for homeowners facing deadlines like Foreclosure, a quick job relocation, or a difficult Divorce settlement. The cash sale provides a guaranteed, fast exit strategy that the traditional market simply cannot offer.

Conclusion

When you look at the two paths, the trade off becomes very clear. The decision comes down to how you value your time and your peace of mind. FSBO means doing 100% of the work to save 6% of the money. You become the marketer, the negotiator, and the project manager for repairs.

On the other hand, selling to WeBuyPropertyNY means doing 0% of the work and still saving the 6%. You bypass the inspections, the repairs, and the waiting games. You get a fair cash offer and close on your terms. If you have been stressing and asking yourself, how can i sell my house fast without a realtor, the cash offer route provides the most direct and secure answer.

FAQs